This poster has had a chip on his shoulder against any software other than Bru'n Water from the onset and should not be trusted, as he is clearly not attempting to be objective. He is essentially shilling for Bru'n Water, which to him is always correct (despite easy to verify serious flaws which would make a statement to that effect impossible for that software). And he is not above providing false data or statements (as I easily demonstrated on another thread) for MME and likely also for other software packages. This should be obvious to anyone who has been following his posts across various threads.
So to recap. i purchased beersmith 3 specifcally because i liked the water tools upgrades. the first brew i tried using the new tools turned out with a mash ph of much lower than the target. after doing some research it turned out that seemed to be happening for majority. hoping i was using the software incorrectly i creating a post asking if anyone HAD luck with the bs3 ph tool. after 1800 views unforunatly not one person chimed in to say it WAS working for them. most that replied said the same thing. its recommending double the amont required to reach there targets and they continued using brunwater. suspiciously one user names silver is money was very persistant that brunwater is incorrect and that bs3 is correct. eventually once said member posted that he indeed hadnt even used bs3 or brunwater for that matter it clicked. he was the author of another obscure program which uses the same method as bs3 to calculate and admitting bs3 as incorrect would also mean his software is incorrect. at that point i i made a new thread based on silver is moneys program mme so he could continue to debate his software and keep the bs3 ph tool thread on track. again said user probably typed 10000 word in a thread in his own words defending bs3 (that hes never tried). it was a yes or no question which he never answered.
the tread made on mme is basically the same as the bs3. nobody can confirm its worked for them or even uses it.
now there is this tread. all ive said is i thought that the ph measurement process is standard and didnt really understand what op was trying to figure out. ive had great luck using brunwater and i check my ph thru the process and have no reason to believe theres anything wrong with it. now silver is money claims im obviously a shill with a chip on my shoulder because i use brunwater with good results.
so a few questions for silver is money.
is anyone that makes the claims i do that they have had better luck with brunwater than bs3s ph tool a shill/incorrect or just me?
when did it become a FACT that brunwater doesnt work? if anyone disagrees are they incorrect?
you said i provided false data which you easily demonstrated was false. can you copy and paste just one instance of that as i think your getting your users confused
you say despite easy to verify serious flaws which would make a statement to that effect impossible for that software. when did this become fact ? seems strange that so many of us are clearly doing it wrong with good results dont you think?
what software do you believe is used/recommended the most?
do you think your know it all / my way or the highway attitude will help get you new users of your software?
you say "This poster has had a chip on his shoulder against any software other than Bru'n Water from the onset and should not be trusted, as he is clearly not attempting to be objective". would you trust someone who defended bs3 to death to have a valid opinion ?YOU HAVENT EVEN USED BS3 but its correct?
i think when you look at the facts its you thats suspect of everything you accuse me of being. clear as day . i have nothing to loose here. you MADE software that uses the same model as bs3 that nobody uses and have ever reason to argue to the death that its correct
i await your answers to these specific questions however fully expect you wont be able to answer then directly. it will be another 10000 word essay on some off topic thing with no answer to the specifc 6 questions asked. just like the bs3 thread. prove me right. please. cheers