Man, I feel for you and I applaud your determination. I hope your problem is fixed. I can't offer up anything that hasn't already been covered here. But, if your problem isn't fixed, maybe you could try a new approach.
Buy a beginners extract kit (new siphon, fermenter, etc) and source your water from somewhere different. The key is that you don't use anything that you are currently using.
If the beer is good, start introducing your system back to your process one component at a time. For example, brew another extract kit using your current water source. If it's still good, brew another one with all the new equipment and then keg it. Maybe even get a new keg/borrow a keg with a picnic tap so the only thing you're introducing is your Co2 setup.
In theory, you're fessing up to having one more bad batch but you should be able to start making good beer. If you use all virgin gear and still have the problem, at least you have eliminated all your components.
I know this isn't the cheapest method but it beats dumping batch after batch down the drain.
Buy a beginners extract kit (new siphon, fermenter, etc) and source your water from somewhere different. The key is that you don't use anything that you are currently using.
If the beer is good, start introducing your system back to your process one component at a time. For example, brew another extract kit using your current water source. If it's still good, brew another one with all the new equipment and then keg it. Maybe even get a new keg/borrow a keg with a picnic tap so the only thing you're introducing is your Co2 setup.
In theory, you're fessing up to having one more bad batch but you should be able to start making good beer. If you use all virgin gear and still have the problem, at least you have eliminated all your components.
I know this isn't the cheapest method but it beats dumping batch after batch down the drain.