In my last batch, my measured OG was 1.080. However, I don't think I had a good mix of my top-off water (after boil volume was 4 gal and topped off to 5 gal). Also, there was a good bit of solid matter in the sample that may have thrown off the sample. I used Windsor yeast, which I understand has low-mid attenuation. Should have thought of adding more water (duh!). My FG was 1.024. My primary hypothesis is that the yeast reached its tolerance for alcohol. I'm bottle conditioning. I know there is a chance that fermentation hadn't yet finished. I'm going to sample a bottle after 1 week and check for pressure. If the bottle is flat (as I suspect) I'll accept the fact that I may have flat beer. If the pressure is significant, then I'll probably have to dump or rebottle. I'm taking notes as I improve my techniques, so, hopefully, I'll be able to improve on hitting my targets going forward. In the meantime, I'd like to have some tricks up my sleeve (like high gravity yeast) for when things don't go as expected.