Grannyknot
Well-Known Member
%$&!# Gareth Bale.
Sell him to Real Madrid already.
Sell him to Real Madrid already.
I didn't say he was overrated.
I also didn't say just because he had a testimonial match meant he had to retire, I only mentioned it to note how long he has been playing.
I just think they have better options at CB.
Although all of them seem to suck at passing back to the keeper.
Man U was absolutely hosed today. I know it was just Jose being polite but he even said they didn't deserve the win. Man U was so much better the first 48 minutes before Nani was sent off for one of the dumbest reds. Vidic had 2 goal quality headers.
I've seen reds for less. Not that it makes it right, but this is the line you walk when you leave all these split second decisions solely down to the ref. Sometimes you're on the receiving end of a howler. That being said, what in the bloody hell is Nani doing with his boot that high?
I get that he was trying to get the ball, but when you're putting your boot up at chest level to control a ball you're assuming the risks when you get it wrong. Nani got it wrong and had to depend on the leniency of the ref. The ref decided no leniency needed.
On another note, apparently a United fan was so incensed with the call that he decided the police needed to be called.
Well from the picture that's a straight red. "intent" has been taken out of alot of the laws of the game in this regard.
Pretty much from the ankle up if you show your studs to an opposing player and make contact, you would be sent off. From the knee up for certain. Chest high? no question.
Well from the picture that's a straight red. "intent" has been taken out of alot of the laws of the game in this regard.
Pretty much from the ankle up if you show your studs to an opposing player and make contact, you would be sent off. From the knee up for certain. Chest high? no question.
Sure, but Arbeloa ran into his foot as much as Nani ran into him. In other words, when Nani raised his foot towards the ball, Arbeloa wasn't there. So he wasn't "showing his studs to an opposing player." He was showing his studs to air and a player ran into that space.
Again, was it an offense? Sure, and I'm not saying he should have been punished. Is it the same as when someone comes in with a two footed, studs up slide tackle? Not IMO.
And no, he didn't ninja kick him in the chest. A ninja kick in the chest is what de jong did to xabi.
Oh, and at this point, I will officially agree to disagree with anyone else on this. I have spoken my piece.
I get that he was trying to get the ball, but when you're putting your boot up at chest level to control a ball you're assuming the risks when you get it wrong. Nani got it wrong and had to depend on the leniency of the ref. The ref decided no leniency needed.
BrewKnurd said:Trying to get the ball. Bicycle kicks involve higher boots than that, and we don't ask what the hell they were doing.
Had there been no one around, no one would question his boot being that high. Of course, there was someone around, but it surely didn't look like Nani knew that, since his eye was on the ball. Which is why, for me, its a yellow. It was obviously a dangerous play, and that's why he doesn't get off with nothing, but its not red in my mind. Of course, I'm nothing but a spectator, so my opinion is worth approximated zilch.
It certainly wasn't this dangerous tho:
Ahhh, good ol' nigel.
Enter your email address to join: