Aside from all the pot smoke in Arcata, there's Redwood Curtain Brewing Company, which is in Arcata, Mad River Brewing Company, in Blue Lake, which is near Eureka, or Lost Coast in Eureka, about 10 min from Arcata/Humboldt University, or lastly there's a brewpub called Humbrews in Arcata, call them and see what they have, They're all on google, been a while since I've been up there, but you should be able to get one from one of those places before going to BevMo.