Skimming hot break or leaving it in, what do you do and why? I skim cause i have a smaller kettle and it helps lower chances of boil over and from what I researched aids in the shelf life of beer( supposedly) and less trub
Last edited:
Yeah i heard it leaving it in makes for clearer beerI skim. As long as I'm standing around watching a boil kettle, might just as well scoop out some of the crap that would otherwise end up in my fermenter.
I get a lot of it just before it reaches a boil.
Jury's out on whether it helps reduce haziness in my finished beers.
Yeah i heard it leaving it in makes for clearer beer
To be honest i never did an experiment myself so its hear say but i believe brulosophy did something on itDidn't know that--sounds counterintuitive. But maybe that stuff helps precipitate some of the haze-forming compounds.
It can help the beer go bright sooner by interacting with flocculating yeast cells, producing floccs with a greater mass therefore drop out at a higher rate. It contains some yeast nutrients as well. I think the main reasons commercial brewers minimise kettle trub is to avoid blocked pipework and harvest slurry with a greater proportion of yeast. In the early days of my brewing journey I kind of liked how it filled the dead space in the bottom of my FVs, but after changing my process less wort solids suits me better.Yeah i heard it leaving it in makes for clearer beer
Im pretty certain skimming vs not skimming is not gonna impact the boldness of the beer, thats recipe, non skimmed from what i heard produces clearer beer, skimmed beer produces more stable longer shelf life beer and less trub in fermenterNo skim. I like bold beers and figure I paid full price for the grain and want every bit of flavor it has to offer. I gelatin every beer except Neipa"s or historic hazy beers so clear is not an issue.
Yeah my recipes are bold. Guess I should have put a wink emoji after the paid full price statement. I do Irish moss at the end of boil aka leaving the hot break and boil hops behind when transferring to the fermenter and gelatin as I said so pretty sure I'm getting everything out of the beer that would shorten shelf life. There may be something to skimming but you wont get all the proteins just from skimming the top IMO. It would surely shorten the time when the protein goes back into solution as there would be less of it to contend with. A long time ago there was similar threads on here and I just decided I drink my beer so quick anyway and it is all kegged so shelf life really wasn't going to be an issue.thats recipe, non skimmed from what i heard produces clearer beer, skimmed beer produces more stable longer shelf life beer and less trub in fermenter
I presume it's the stuff that floats to the top just as the kettle's coming to the boil. I never realised that was hot break. Mine looks like curds roiling around in the clear wort while it's boiling. I don't know how you'd skim that out. Doesn't it all settle down with the trub as the beer cools and mostly gets left behind in the kettle.
As an aside, I recently got a conical fermenter and thought that once I'd removed the hop bags, I'd tip everything, trub and all, into the fermenter and let it stand for an hour or so and then purge the cone of the trub before pitching the yeast. Has anyone tried this?
I'll go with that. Just depends on the day. Bigger grain bills in my system tend to have more hot break, and sometimes I just feel like grabbing my wire sieve and getting it out of there. Other times I'm busy doing other things, and I let it go. Doesn't seem to affect the clarity or shelf life of my beers. Less hot break=less scrubbing the sides of the BK too so there's that.No choice for "sometimes"?
Any reference on that reading material? I had suspected that might be the case. I always thought when a stout was coming to a boil that the initial foam was a great indicator of what the head on the beer would look like. It matches up pretty much spot on.I got tired of boil overs and started skimming the foam from the top of the kettle as it formed. I had less incidence and thought I'd cured the problem. After about two batches of beer, I quickly noticed that my brews didn't have that whipped cream head I had taken so much pride in.
After reading just a bit, I found that the components of that initial foam are what makes for a full head of foam.
Never had a problem with head retention from skimminghttps://crescentcitybrewtalk.com/head-on-beer/
Here's one reference I used to figure out what I did wrong.
Never had a problem with head retention from skimming
brewed a 1080 stout 3 days ago with what i thought was compromised yeast from hot shipping , skimmed the HB, its almost at FG 1080 to 1020 in 3 days is pretty good and a good indication of healthy yeast 3 more days should be fully done,the yeast did not suffer at all idk what i will find out, i think i would have already after many skimmed batches, at the end of the day im starting to believe it doesn’t matter skimmed or not skimmed but to say skimming will cause problems is just not trueThere are components in that mess you're skimming like free amino acids which the yeast needs just a little bit later during fermentation. Go ahead and skim . . . you'll find out.