would you tweak this one or leave it alone.
8 1/4 lbs basic malt 2 row malt
1/4 lbs basic malt smoked over apple wood to very smoky aroma.
1/2 lbs dark rye malt
1/2 lbs chocalte malt
1 oz northern brewer hops pelete bittering 1 hour boil alpha 9.4%
1/2 oz perle flavor 15 min boil...