I keep a commercial brew log and occasionally post the reviews in the sticky in this subforum. I try to be objective with my "scoring" system - 10 points each for Appearance, Aroma, Flavor, Mouthfeel, and Overall.
Here, I added the scores in a total column, then sorted from best to worst. I'd like to re-score Hoegaarden and Stone IPA in particular. While I like those two beers, I'd choose several from further down the list over them. However, for the most part, the list reflects my taste. It's not a comprehensive list of every beer I've every had, but I try to make an entry for anything new that I try. I'm enjoying keeping a record of beers I've enjoyed (or hated).
Hoegaarden - Hoegaarden
Gordon - Oskar Blues
Stone IPA - Stone
Espresso Oak Aged Yeti - Great Divide
Oak Aged Yeti Imperial Stout - Great Divide
Hefe-Weizen - Paulaner
Bigfoot 2009 - Sierra Nevada
Mephistopheles Stout - Avery
Saison Dupont Vieille Provision - Brasserie Dupont
Hop Rod Rye - Bear Republic
Supplication - Russian River
Old Rasputin - North Coast
Delirium Nocturnum - Huyghe
Hardcore IPA - Brew Dog
Little Sumpin' Sumpin' - Lagunitas
Divine Reserve 11 - St Arnold
Double Black IPA - Alaskan Brewing
Avatar Jasmine IPA - Elysian
Maredsous 10 Tripel - Duvel Moortgat
Koningshoeven Dubbel - Brouwerij de Koningshoeven
Collaboration not Litigation Ale - Avery / Russian River
Salvation - Russian River
Hobgoblin - Wychwood
Banana Bread Beer - Wells & Young's
Wisconsin Belgian Red - New Glarus
OREgasmic Ale - Rogue
Strongbow - Bulmers
Sublimely Self-Righteous Ale - Stone
Damnation (Golden Ale) - Russian River
Mama's Little Yella Pils - Oskar Blues
Dale's Pale Ale - Oskar Blues
Maredsous 8 Dubbel - Duvel Moortgat
Trippel - New Belgium
Winter Stout (09) - St George
La Folie (Lips of Faith) - New Belgium
Namaste - Dogfish Head
Chocolate Stout - Rogue
Milk Stout - Left Hand
HopDevil - Victory
Curieux - Allagash
Kingfisher - Kingfisher?
Drop Top Amber - Widmer
Three Philosophers - Ommegang
Brother Thelonious - North Coast
Chipotle Ale - Rogue
Old Chub - Oskar Blues
Delirium Tremens - Huyghe
Anniversary 2008 - Sierra Nevada
Monk's Cafe Flemish Sour Ale - Brouwerij Van Steenberge N.V.
Bigfoot 2011 - Sierra Nevada
Session Black - Full Sail
Censored (The Kronic) - Lagunitas
Old English Porter Unplugged - New Glarus
Bashah - Stone/Brew Dog
Ranger IPA - New Belgium
Broken Halo IPA - Widmer
Stella Artois - Stella Artois
Double Bock - Sam Adams
Tripel - Westmalle
Maximus - Lagunitas
Levitation - Stone
Mocha Porter - Rogue
Nefarious Ten Pin - Ska
Blackthorn - Constellation Europe
Pine Belt Pale Ale - Southern Star
Chicken Killer - Santa Fe
Dogma - Brew Dog
1554 - New Belgium
Southern Hemisphere Harvest - Sierra Nevada
Mana Wheat - Maui Brewing Company
Porter - Michelob
Immortal IPA - Elysian
#100 Barleywine - Nøgne Ø
Paradox Isle of Arran - Brew Dog
Gubna - Oskar Blues
Hopus - Lefebvre
XS Imperial Red Ale - Rogue
Xingu - Cervejaria Sul Brasileira
Organic Cherry - Samuel Smith
Theobroma - Dogfish Head
Shiner Holiday Cheer - Spoetzl
Monk's Brew - Abbey Beverage Co.
Curve Ball - Pyramid
Samael's Oak Aged Ale - Avery
Red Stripe Lager - Red Stripe
Golden Wheat - Anheuser-Busch
Triple Bock - Sam Adams
Here, I added the scores in a total column, then sorted from best to worst. I'd like to re-score Hoegaarden and Stone IPA in particular. While I like those two beers, I'd choose several from further down the list over them. However, for the most part, the list reflects my taste. It's not a comprehensive list of every beer I've every had, but I try to make an entry for anything new that I try. I'm enjoying keeping a record of beers I've enjoyed (or hated).
Hoegaarden - Hoegaarden
Gordon - Oskar Blues
Stone IPA - Stone
Espresso Oak Aged Yeti - Great Divide
Oak Aged Yeti Imperial Stout - Great Divide
Hefe-Weizen - Paulaner
Bigfoot 2009 - Sierra Nevada
Mephistopheles Stout - Avery
Saison Dupont Vieille Provision - Brasserie Dupont
Hop Rod Rye - Bear Republic
Supplication - Russian River
Old Rasputin - North Coast
Delirium Nocturnum - Huyghe
Hardcore IPA - Brew Dog
Little Sumpin' Sumpin' - Lagunitas
Divine Reserve 11 - St Arnold
Double Black IPA - Alaskan Brewing
Avatar Jasmine IPA - Elysian
Maredsous 10 Tripel - Duvel Moortgat
Koningshoeven Dubbel - Brouwerij de Koningshoeven
Collaboration not Litigation Ale - Avery / Russian River
Salvation - Russian River
Hobgoblin - Wychwood
Banana Bread Beer - Wells & Young's
Wisconsin Belgian Red - New Glarus
OREgasmic Ale - Rogue
Strongbow - Bulmers
Sublimely Self-Righteous Ale - Stone
Damnation (Golden Ale) - Russian River
Mama's Little Yella Pils - Oskar Blues
Dale's Pale Ale - Oskar Blues
Maredsous 8 Dubbel - Duvel Moortgat
Trippel - New Belgium
Winter Stout (09) - St George
La Folie (Lips of Faith) - New Belgium
Namaste - Dogfish Head
Chocolate Stout - Rogue
Milk Stout - Left Hand
HopDevil - Victory
Curieux - Allagash
Kingfisher - Kingfisher?
Drop Top Amber - Widmer
Three Philosophers - Ommegang
Brother Thelonious - North Coast
Chipotle Ale - Rogue
Old Chub - Oskar Blues
Delirium Tremens - Huyghe
Anniversary 2008 - Sierra Nevada
Monk's Cafe Flemish Sour Ale - Brouwerij Van Steenberge N.V.
Bigfoot 2011 - Sierra Nevada
Session Black - Full Sail
Censored (The Kronic) - Lagunitas
Old English Porter Unplugged - New Glarus
Bashah - Stone/Brew Dog
Ranger IPA - New Belgium
Broken Halo IPA - Widmer
Stella Artois - Stella Artois
Double Bock - Sam Adams
Tripel - Westmalle
Maximus - Lagunitas
Levitation - Stone
Mocha Porter - Rogue
Nefarious Ten Pin - Ska
Blackthorn - Constellation Europe
Pine Belt Pale Ale - Southern Star
Chicken Killer - Santa Fe
Dogma - Brew Dog
1554 - New Belgium
Southern Hemisphere Harvest - Sierra Nevada
Mana Wheat - Maui Brewing Company
Porter - Michelob
Immortal IPA - Elysian
#100 Barleywine - Nøgne Ø
Paradox Isle of Arran - Brew Dog
Gubna - Oskar Blues
Hopus - Lefebvre
XS Imperial Red Ale - Rogue
Xingu - Cervejaria Sul Brasileira
Organic Cherry - Samuel Smith
Theobroma - Dogfish Head
Shiner Holiday Cheer - Spoetzl
Monk's Brew - Abbey Beverage Co.
Curve Ball - Pyramid
Samael's Oak Aged Ale - Avery
Red Stripe Lager - Red Stripe
Golden Wheat - Anheuser-Busch
Triple Bock - Sam Adams