Black Barley Substitutes

[hukdizzle]

Going to be brewing an RIS here soon, here are my two choices from the brew shop for a sub for black barley.

Simpsons Roasted Barley

or

Simpsons Black Malt

I have checked out the stats on both malts on the Simpsons website but neither really seem to match up with the measurements in BeerSmith. Which grain would you pick?

 

[BigEd]

The roasted barley is what you want.