You collected 5 pints of slurry! I usually get about 2.5 pints from a 6.5 gallon brew. That's a lot of wasted beer. Also there is yeast in all layers of the sediment.
Purists will tell you to calculate the required yeast cells for a beer and then make a starter..
I used to do that, but found it was just too much effort for relatively no gain. At the end of fermentation a beer will have roughly 6X the recommended yeast for pitching to a similar gravity beer. So factoring some loss over time in the fermenter and delay from when I harvest the yeast, I generally try to pitch roughly a third of a cake into a similar gravity beer if re-using the yeast within a month - no starter, just drain the liquid and pitch. If it is a higher gravity beer I'll pitch maybe a half the cake.
I have straight-pitched yeast after several months without issues. It is not something that I ever plan to do, but sometimes you just got to brew and all you have is an old cake in the fridge. In that case I would pitch the whole cake. Done this a few times, and never had an issue.