As in good idea to give beer as a gift? I think its great. There is a lot more work and devotion involved in making 2 batches of beer than going to the store to buy plates or silverware. It's much more of a gift IMO. It reminds me of receiving a card on my b-day from my kids. If they make it, I save it. If it's bought, it normally ends up in thw recycling after a few weeks. Much more of a personal touch