Most people who know what they're talking about would not say this. Many end suction pumps have horizontal discharges...
I have no idea the specific pump you're using but you could have shorter lifespan due to premature bearing wear if the pumps are not designed to be mounted in that position but considering the duty you'll put them through, you should Still get many years either way.
With the details you put into your build, you probably already thought of this... I haven't read any of this thread but I'd make sure those pump casings don't hold up any water and they're fully drained each time as you'll start growing nasties in no time.
I'm going to guess that you don't own a March or Chugger style pump. The problem with your logic is that this isn't a suction pump, it's a non-self-priming centrifugal impeller pump. They rely on a fully flooded housing to begin to push liquid out the outlet. In that circumstance, you want to ensure the outlet is at least the same height as the inlet since the only way to ensure that liquid will begin to pump is to expel all air from the head to avoid churn and
Thanks for the suggestion. I looked into it and I am certainly considering reorienting them; cavitation was definitely a problem. I am concerned about getting liquid into the motor housing though with the pump mounted horizontally; have you had an issue with this?
Sent from my iPhone using Home Brew
Most people who know what they're talking about would not say this. Many end suction pumps have horizontal discharges...
It's certainly a concern, since having the pumps below the liquid is necessary for proper operation, but the disadvantage is that you can splash the motor assembly. An interesting solution was the jig that Kal built on his pump stand that included stainless shields to guard against the accidental splash of wort. Check that out here: http://theelectricbrewery.com/pumps?page=5
That's not a bad design; I like how it allows the housing to still vent so well. I may do something similar with a horizontal orientation.
Thanks! That was the intent: Protect from splashes (which actually don't seem to happen much at all given that my pumps are on the lower shelf of the table), but not impede airflow in any way so that they continue to run cool. The back of the fan has a spinning blade inside that keeps the motor cool so you want air to flow through freely.That's not a bad design; I like how it allows the housing to still vent so well.
I apologize for the apparent tone of my post; it was not my intention to come off that way.
My point still stands RE cavitation. The orientation of the pump as it stands will not cause cavitation; it will simply be driven by NPSHa & r. If possible, I would look at following Chugger's recommendation of vertical with top mount motor so the pump casing is self-draining.
I think maybe you misunderstood Chugger's recommendation, it reads, "You can mount the pump horizontally, vertically and upside down.* However, if you mount the pump vertically do not have the motor facing up." That said, reality and theory are often two different things. These pumps just plain don't work as well when facing up for whatever reason, in my experience. Dmarc85, I see that you reoriented them. Let us know if you have more or less success with them next time?
just curious, what happened to the stainless tray in the brew stand?
Congrats on the first batch in the fermenter.... did you really use 1 pound (at 75 mins) of cascade in that beer?
I'm happy to say that I now make far more beer than I can drink and I could realistically make far more beer than I could even fit in my three door cooler!
Interesting labels on your growlers.
What did you you to create them, what paper did you print on and is that a QR code?
Thanks
Brent
I struggled with my trub in my shirron chiller plate on my first batch, so tonight I sterilIzed it again after noticing a funny smell from that unit.
Since my last brew day, I've mounted the chiller on the wood stand; I've also hose clamped a few connections that worried me (mostly incoming). I resterilized the inline oxygenation system that I purchased from morebeer.com as well.
View attachment 230630
View attachment 230631
Prior to this build I've only used IC's to cool my wort, but tonight I was really impressed at how fast and simple my Shirron plate chiller was.
Sent from my iPhone using Home Brew
Enter your email address to join: