I think that's the problem I'm mashing too high. So I'll try that with my next batch.
It's a 10-gallon batch with: 20 lbs 2-Row, 4 lbs 12 oz Rye Malt, 2 lbs 8 oz Midnight Wheat, 2 lbs 8 oz Caramunich, 1 lb 4 oz carafa III, and 1lb 2.4 oz Crystal 60L. My OG was 1.081 and my FG was 1.024. Yeast...