You'll get a lot of use out of the original ones. Remember they've really only been used ONCE before.
A lot of folks blame them for lack of carbonation when they open the bottles...but when you question them further, you find out the reason their bottles aren't carbed isn't because of the gaskets on the bottles, it's because they opened them TOO SOON. A pint bottle needs 4-5 weeks at 70 degrees for average gravity beers to carb up usually.